Ward (Churchill), the happy academic is worried about the tenure…

I came home from teaching Tuesday night (great class, btw– we met at Ypsilanti’s fine coffee shop, Bombadil’s), and in the course of my surfing by the mid-level cable channels at around 10 pm, I came across some right-wing show (“Scarborough Country,” I believe it’s called) talking about a tenure controversy at the University of Colorado (Boulder) involving Ward Churchill. In the nutshell, Churchill wrote an essay called “‘Some People Push Back’ On The Justice of Roosting Chickens,” which is more or less about how the 9/11 attacks on the U.S. was (as the title suggests) an example of the chickens coming home to roost, so to speak. In other words, Churchill says it’s not surprising that the U.S. was attacked on 9/11 considering the various invasions and repressions that the U.S. has inflicted on the Islamic world, especially since the first war in Iraq.

It is Churchill’s way with words has really gotten him in a bit of trouble. Let me quote at length here from the above link:

“As to those in the World Trade Center . . .

“Well, really. Let’s get a grip here, shall we? True enough, they were civilians of a sort. But innocent? Gimme a break. They formed a technocratic corps at the very heart of America’s global financial empire the “mighty engine of profit” to which the military dimension of U.S. policy has always been enslaved, and they did so both willingly and knowingly. Recourse to “ignorance” a derivative, after all, of the word “ignore” counts as less than an excuse among this relatively well-educated elite. To the extent that any of them were unaware of the costs and consequences to others of what they were involved in and in many cases excelling at it was because of their absolute refusal to see. More likely, it was because they were too busy braying, incessantly and self-importantly, into their cell phones, arranging power lunches and stock transactions, each of which translated, conveniently out of sight, mind and smelling distance, into the starved and rotting flesh of infants. If there was a better, more effective, or in fact any other way of visiting some penalty befitting their participation upon the little Eichmanns inhabiting the sterile sanctuary of the twin towers, I’d really be interested in hearing about it.

“The men who flew the missions against the WTC and Pentagon were not “cowards.” That distinction properly belongs to the “firm-jawed lads” who delighted in flying stealth aircraft through the undefended airspace of Baghdad, dropping payload after payload of bombs on anyone unfortunate enough to be below including tens of thousands of genuinely innocent civilians while themselves incurring all the risk one might expect during a visit to the local video arcade. Still more, the word describes all those “fighting men and women” who sat at computer consoles aboard ships in the Persian Gulf, enjoying air-conditioned comfort while launching cruise missiles into neighborhoods filled with random human beings. Whatever else can be said of them, the men who struck on September 11 manifested the courage of their convictions, willingly expending their own lives in attaining their objectives.”

Now, the line that’s really gotten Churchill in trouble (judging from what I’ve found on the ‘net) is that one about the “little Eichmanns.” Personally, I could only make it through about half of the article, not because of the points that Churchill was trying to make (more on that in a second), but because I just thought the essay was pretty poorly written.

Anyway, Churchill published this essay (I think) on September 12, 2001, a date on which I think it is fair to say that emotions were running mighty high all across the country, regardless of your political bent. And now, three and a half years later, he has suddenly landed on the proverbial hotseat. The Colorado Board of Regents is meeting today or tomorrow to decide whether or not to fire him.

There have been plenty of calls for his dismissal– here is an editorial from the Rocky Mountain News and a column from the Naples Daily News by Paul Campos (a law professor at U of Colorado), and here is a letter written by the governor of Colorado which walks an interesting line about firing Churchill. And you can imagine the smirking remarks on conservative talk TV. Essentially, these guys (and many of the editorials and columns) just cannot believe that this Churchill guy can get away with saying this stuff because he has tenure and cannot be fired. Can you believe it?!

Well, as a tenured and happy academic myself, I have a few thoughts:

  • I don’t know where these conservative editorial writers, TV guys, and columnist (though I don’t think Campos is easily identified as a “conservative” per se) have been, but the idea that the World Trade Center was a “military target” and that we “asked for it” on September 11 is not exactly new. No less than that radical magazine Newsweek ran a large cover-page article called “The Politics of Rage: Why Do They Hate Us?” by Fareed Zakaria, who is a frequent commentator on ABC News and a pretty good writer. Now, obviously, Zakaria’s approach is much more gentle and level than Churchill’s. But the point I’m trying to make is that the idea that, from the view of the Islamic world, especially countries like Iraq, the U.S. deserved being attacked is not that unique. And at least this guy, Rocky Mountain News columnist Bill Johnson, seems to get it.
  • The fact that Churchill is an American Indian who was (until he recently resigned over all this) chair of the department of Ethnic Studies and who has been involved in a variety of leftist causes isn’t endearing him to the “everyman” crowd in Colorado. And the fact that his scholarly work has included writings about the genocide of Native Americans, Marxists organization and American Indian communities, and about justifiable violence that leads to positive change aren’t exactly helping his cause either. Indeed, I have to think that if this would not be a story at all if Churchill was a white guy working in (for example) the Political Science department.
  • The folks calling for Churchill’s head keep asking some version of what they think is a rhetorical question: “Shouldn’t this guy be fired for saying this, even if he has tenure?” But in my mind (and lots of other happy academic minds, I suspect), the clear answer is “no.” The writings and thoughts of Churchill are precisely the reason for the tenure system.

    Contrary to popular belief, tenure doesn’t make it impossible for a professor to lose his or her job. For example, if Churchill didn’t show up for his teaching and meetings, if he showed up drunk, and so forth, he could get fired. If he committed a crime or sexually harassed his students or colleagues, he could get fired. If he actually committed an act of terrorism, he could get fired. If the school went “belly up” financially, he could get fired (that almost happened at a place where I us
    ed to teach). And these things, my non-academic friends, are the sort of reasons why people in the “real world” get fired, too.

    However, the point of tenure is to protect the free exchange of ideas, especially when those ideas are controversial and they incite such powerful reactions. And that’s because it is the exchange of ideas, controversial or not, that makes the whole concept of a university work.

Look, I don’t agree with Churchill. I don’t agree with academics like Kevin MacDonald either. He testified in an infamous Jewish holocaust denier case and he has written about the vast Jewish conspiracy, arguments which, based on the summaries I’ve seen, seem pretty bizarre to me. And he too was in danger of losing his tenured-position because of his views. I think a lot of Noam Chompsky’s political views are a bit crazy too, though I’ve never heard of Chompsky being in danger of being fired. There are lots and lots of academics who have controversial ideas. But the answer is not to fire him. The answer is to engage these ideas and writings with counter-arguments that take on the various case.

And again, that’s why it is important in academic settings to have controversial ideas: the debate and exchange of different ideas and views furthers “Knowledge” itself, and without this exchange, higher education is pretty much pointless.

We’ll see what happens. But one thing that does concern me is that when I did a Google search for “Ward Churchill” blog, all I came across were blog entries and other posts from folks on the right and/or not understanding the point of tenure suggesting that Churchill does indeed deserve to get the boot. I don’t want to be an alarmist here, but it isn’t too much of a leap to suggest that if folks like Churchill are going to get fired, then happy academics (like me) who have less controversial but still not “popular” views might be vulnerable, too.

Er, maybe I ought to keep my happy academic mouth shut.

BTW, no kidding, I really did finish posting this at “9:11.”

UPDATE:
I came across this press statement from Churchill, where he tries to explain himself. A bit more reasonable than what he’s trying to explain, IMO.

UPDATE #2:
The Denver Post is reporting that the board of regents at the University of Colorado almost certainly will not ask to fire Churchill. A couple of interesting points the article:

  • ” Lawmakers in the state House on Wednesday unanimously approved a resolution denouncing the Boulder professor…” Oy vey. I hope after that they decided to once again denounce Janet Jackson’s wardrobe malfunction and then unanimously approved God, apple pie, and the fourth of July.
  • “[T]he regents cannot strip Churchill of tenure without due process, [CU regent] Carrigan said. At their meeting today, they will speak out against Churchill’s essay and receive legal advice, he said.” This regent goes on to point out that the reasons for dismissal are pretty much spelled out, and they don’t include having disagreeable opinions.
  • About the possibility of being fired, Churchill said “They really don’t want to do that unless they want me owning this university,” and, pointing out that if he were fired he would sue, “My problem would be fighting off the number of lawyers that would want to be involved. This is exactly what I’m protected from – an attempt to take my job on the basis of a difference of opinion on a burning issue.” I hope he’s right….

Wanna read Wayne Booth's new book?

Sure you do. So does Collin, Jenny, Clancy and potentially a bunch of other people too.

You can go check out those blogs for the skinny on this, but basically, I think they’re proposing a seminar/discussion/”Carnival” where we read and blog about Booth’s new book, The Rhetoric of Rhetoric. This sounds like a great idea to me.

Hopefully, I will be participating in this (at least some) because I am a big Booth fan and because I actually own this book. I bought it at MLA and started reading it while on the exercise bike at the gym where my in-laws live. But I might not be participating that much because I am super-duper swamped with school work, textbook writing, and– oh yeah, that pesky scholarship. Deep sigh.

A great idea though.

Which glam rocker are you?

david johansen
You’re David Johansen, the lead singer of the New
York Dolls. You are a sexy bitch who growls
like a werewolf but can swagger better than
Jagger.. You’re confident, hipper than
everyone, and you know it. You’re not afraid to
wear women’s clothes because you’re a real man.
No one is cooler than you, you tart.
Watch out for ugly facial hair in the
future…alright?

Which rad old school 70’s glam icon are you? (with pics)
brought to you by Quizilla

I dunno about this, personally… I don’t really see myself as any glam rock star, but a kind of amusing quiz.

The first amendment, the 'net, and "the kids today"

There were two articles posted on tech-rhet yesterday and which I saw in a variety of different places. The first, called “Freedom of what?” as reported on CNN.com, is about high school students’ lack of awareness of the first amendment. Perhaps a more helpful link is to the press release about the study John S. and James L. Knight Foundation, which is the organization that paid for the study in the first place. To quote from the bulletted list of findings published on that site:

  • Nearly three-fourths of high school students either do not know how they feel about the First Amendment or admit they take it for granted.
  • Seventy-five percent erroneously think flag burning is illegal.
  • Half believe the government can censor the Internet.
  • More than a third think the First Amendment goes too far in the rights it guarantees.

The other article is “Study finds parents perform better online than teens” in CNNMoney. As the article says, “The study showed that teens quickly succumb to Internet ennui and, unlike their parents, give up quickly on sites that are difficult to navigate ‘When using Web sites, teenagers have a lower success rate than adults and they’re also easily bored,’ the study concluded. To work for teens, Web sites must be simple, but not childish, and supply plenty of interactive features.'” This study was a lot smaller and (it seems to me) a bit less systematic than the first amendment study, so take with an appropriate seasoning.

On the one hand, these conclusions are hardly surprising and they perhaps do say something unique about “today’s youth.” A high school aged person has always lived in a country where free speech and protest have been brought into question and where all kinds of rights of expression have been restricted. So of course they think that the basic constitutional principal of being able to freely say what you want goes “too far.” And it is equally not that surprising to me that teenagers get bored easily with web research since they seem to me to get “bored” with just about any kind of research.

On the other hand, the conclusions of both of these studies also suggest to me that the “kids today” are pretty much like the kids 20, 50, 100, and 1000 years ago in that they are apathetic about things that don’t have to do directly with them. Note the first bullet from the first amendment study results: most students don’t know how the first amendment works or they take it for granted. And the study on internet usage points out that teenagers are easily bored with web searches, especially if the web site doesn’t contain elements to interest them.

(As an aside here: I kind of feel the same way as the teenagers in terms of web searching. I don’t have a lot of patience for web sites that don’t give me what I want in an easy to navigate way. Maybe it is actually the more techno-savvy that have less patience with the web….)

So I’m not really convinced that there is something unique about the kids now and the kids when I was a kid. I mean, if you asked a bunch of teenagers in my high school twenty some-odd years ago about the first amendment, I suspect you would get some similar answers. And the idea that “grown-ups” are better at using various research tools (nowadays, it is the web, but back then, it would have been print resources) than high school kids isn’t exactly news either.

So don’t worry; the kids are alright. We just have to teach them, that’s all. The scary thing is that in the current political culture in this country, a lot of these students are likely to not get the full story on the first amendment anytime soon.

Fighting the losing handwriting battle

See this article, “Teachers answer call for cursive,” published in The State, which is apparently the state newspaper of South Carolina. A couple of interesting quotes and points:

  • “The two-day training in Columbia that begins Tuesday is run by Zaner-Bloser Educational Publishers, which bills itself as a leading publisher of handwriting and language arts texts for children in kindergarten through middle school.” Hmm… you don’t suppose this company has a business interest in promoting handwriting, now do you?
  • “The company is ramping up a handwriting training initiative built around this sales pitch: Starting this March, college-bound high school students who take the new SAT must write a detailed essay in 25 minutes.” This is kind of a curious claim because I was under the impression that these writing samples were going to be typed. They are going to be scored by readers via computer; does this mean that readers will be reading PDF versions of hand-written essays?
  • “We’re hearing an outcry from teachers in middle and high school who cannot read students’ handwriting. They want it taught in the elementary school,” [Priscilla Mullins, a national product manager for Zaner-Bloser] said.

    With the evolution of wireless, hand-held computers capable of converting handwriting into electronic text, good cursive skills could prove critical, she said.

    “We want to make a connection between handwriting and technology,” Mullins said.

    (Yeah, I bet you want to make the connection between handwriting and technology…).

Mind you, I’m not completely against handwriting instruction. My son, a second grader, has worked a lot on his handwriting this year, and they’ve been working on cursive writing, too. And that’s all fine and good. But just because you learn how to write in cursive doesn’t mean you keep writing in cursive as a test-taking teenager.

CSS Overload

As careful readers will recall from a past entry, I made a decision a while ago with my English 444 class to actually “geek it up” a notch and include Eric Meyer’s book, Cascading Style Sheets: The Definitive Guide. We’re reading that book right now, which is one of the reasons why I haven’t been posting here lately. Basically, I decided that we’d spend the first month or so of the class getting down “the tools” and then we’d get on to everything else. So we’ve spent some time talking about basic HTML of course, and also server software tools, HTML editing software (Dreamweaver in particular), and a little bit of PhotoShop. We’re spending two weeks on talking about CSS things, mostly as they relate to the Meyer book.

I need to take a bit of a break from reading it right now; and yet I can’t leave it completely behind. So a chance to blog a few thoughts:

  • I’m about halfway through the book (many of my students are further), and I can now say without question that I know about 1000 times more about CSS than I did before I started. Which is not to say that I really “know” what I’m doing here.
  • In some interesting and surprising ways, my 444 students are being real troopers about all this. Not even a little bit of whining or complaining, and several students have said they’re very glad we’re reading it. I have to say, if I were a student in this class right now, I’m not so sure I’d have as rosy of an attitude, so I really have to hand it to them.
  • Meyer is an extremely good writer. In fact, if nothing else, I think it is fair to say that this is a book that is an excellent example of the oh-so-common genre “manual.”
  • Having said that, I find myself putting stuff he says into four basic categories:
  • Explanations of CSS things I knew about before but which I understand much better now;
  • Explanations of CSS (and other ‘net) things I didn’t know about before but which I feel much better for knowing now;
  • Explanations of things that I am sure are in some sense important but which make absolutely no sense to me; and
  • Explanations of things that I may or may not understand but which are completely irrelevant. For example, at one point, Meyer explains the CSS code for stretching text. The only problem is that since no browser actually supports this feature, it is merely something CSS can do in theory.
  • It’s going to be a while (maybe forever) before I’m able to do the sort of fancy CSS stuff that makes blogs or other CMS systems look really cool.
  • If I were to do this again, I think I’d pick something that is more of a “CSS light” kind of text. I’m torn about this, though. On the one hand, I am glad we’re really getting into the nitty-gritty of the code with this book, and I think my students are thankful for the experience, too. On the other hand, spending 2 weeks on this stuff is perhaps over-kill.

Oh well. Back to the CSS mines.

They added digital pants!

Will had a sleep-over last night, so Annette and I went out for a happy hour and an early dinner at the Sidetrack with friends/colleagues from work, and then we went to see an early showing of Sideways. Pretty good movie, we thought, though we don’t have much to compare it to because this is the only Oscar contender we’ve seen this year. Lots of DVDs at home, and lots of kid movies in the theaters.

Anyway, we got home and were channel-surfing and came across Animal House on VH-1. What a classic– I can’t remember the last time I saw that movie all the way through, but it certainly is a flick burned into my memory.

Now, obviously, VH-1 et al had to do A LOT of editing of the many uses of “shit” and “fuck,” and of the various boob scenes. That’s typical of a movie like this, and it’s usually pretty obvious what and when something is being edited out. But there was one kind of editing I hadn’t seen before: digitally added pants.

There’s a scene about two-thirds of the way through the movie where the frat guy Boon is dropping in unexpectedly on his girlfriend Katy. It’s established earlier that Boon and Katy are “serious” and in love, but Katy thinks that the Deltas are a bunch of immature drunk idiots and that Boon really ought to grow up and leave that all behind. She is of course right. Anyway, Boon surprises Katy, who is standing there in a night shirt and who is obviously uncomfortable about his dropping by. And we learn pretty quickly why that’s the case as a male voice calls out from the back room. Boon is of course mad and storms away.

Here’s where we get to the edit. It turns out that the male voice in Katy’s bedroom is none other than the English professor guy (the one who is teaching a class earlier in the movie and who gets them all high), played by Donald Sutherland. In the original version of the movie, he comes out, wearing only a heavy cardigan sweater, his bare legs apparent for all to see. The professor exchanges a kiss and some banter with Katy, and then he goes into the kitchen in the background where he reaches up to get something from the cupboard, raising up the sweater and exposing his bare ass in the process. Ha ha, bare ass.

In the edited version, Sutherland’s character comes out, but this time he is wearing khaki trousers. He gets something from the cupboard and all we see are his khaki covered ass. Now, either they shot two versions of this scene just for such a purpose (I think not), or they actually added digital clothing.

Assuming it is the digital pants, this strikes me as kind of odd for at least two reasons. First, this the first time I can recall seeing a movie where they added digital clothing. There must be others, but none come to mind. Second, this strikes me as a pretty significant edit because the fact that he comes out dressed not like a guy who just had sex with Katy and is instead dressed like, well, a college professor on his way to class, kind of erases the implied sex scene.

I don’t want to belabor this– after all, we’re talking about Animal House here– but I’d have to wonder what someone who hadn’t seen the original would think of a scene like that. Wouldn’t they be pretty surprised to see the “real” movie, sans pants?

Five thoughts on Social Security

It’s been a while since I’ve posted anything remotely political here and social security has been on my mind lately (with all the various NPR talk show coverage of it), so I thought I’d post five brief thoughts on the whole mess:

  • After listening to various pundits and such over the last few weeks talking about the future of the Social Security system, it is very clear to me that no one— not on the right nor the left, within the administration nor “neutral” government offices, within think tanks and/or universities nor within diners and/or on the street– has a freakin’ clue what’s going to happen with the future of Social Security. It’s all guess work at best.
  • I’m 38 (soon to be 39) years old, and all the people I know in my general age group and income bracket assume that they aren’t going to get a whole heck of a lot of money from Social Security at retirement no matter what they do to the system. Personally, I have always thought of Social Security as simply a tax I pay to support old people, and by the time I get to be an old person, there ain’t going to be much money left. Of course, this is why I (and everyone else I know in my age group and income bracket) have some kind of retirement plan. And of course, this is also why people of my age group but who aren’t saving for retirement for some reason (they don’t have the money to save, they’re just aren’t thinking about it, etc.) are going to be a lot worse off than old people today.
  • While I have mixed feelings about privatization of the system, I am on the whole against it and I think the people who are for it are self-deluded. The kind of person all for this is the same kind of person who thinks that they are so much smarter than everyone else that they can do a better job of investing the money themselves. This is the kind of person who doesn’t buy into a mutual fund or take his money to a professional, but rather just “plays the market.” It’s also the kind of person who is pretty confident that when they go to a casino they are “smart” enough to consistently win. Las Vegas was built on the “wisdom” of these idiots.
  • What the democrats and others against reform really should do is launch a campaign showing old people of the future sitting around having to make choices about medicine or food, living in horrifying conditions, and then have this person talk about how all was going great with their social security fund until the market just tanked. In other words, the folks against this ought to take a page from Carl “Turd Blossom” Rowe’s playbook and scare the shit out of people.
  • I predict that Social Security reform is going to be Bush’s Waterloo. Either he is going to not get it and he’ll manage to waste too much of his “political capital” in the process, or he will get it, old people will get angry, and there will be hell to pay in the mid-term elections in 2006. You read it here first.