Two more quick things about the whole Ward Churchill matter

* While surfing around today, I came across this post from Timothy “Easily Distracted” Burke. He makes a lot of good points, like this:

Churchill’s scholarly oeuvre is practically a guided tour of every trope of identity politics: polemical extensions of the concept of genocide into every possible institutional or social interaction between the colonized and colonizer, erasures of any historical or programmatic distinctions between colonizers in different eras or systems, reduction of all history and contemporary society into a sociologically and morally simple binary schema of colonizer and colonized (hence the remark that the people in the Twin Towers were “little Eichmanns” while Iraqis are literally infantilized into starving babies and nothing more), pervasive indictments of systems of representation, and aggressive assertions of exclusive cultural, moral, political and economic ownership of anything and everything connected with a particular identity group (Native Americans in this case).

Of course, if this polemic approach to identity politics in scholarship were grounds for dismissal from a tenure-track position, then there would be a lot of pretty famous and not so famous academics looking for work. And as polarizing as Churchill seems to be, that is not a reason to fire the guy for speaking his mind.

* Here’s a copy of an email I sent to the University of Colorado Board of regents:

Dear Colorado Board of Regents members:

I am writing for two reasons. First, I applaud the fact that you did not give into public pressure and “simply fire” Professor Ward Churchill because of the controversy surrounding his scholarship and speaking engagements. Second, as you follow your procedures and review Professor Churchill’s tenure at CU, I urge you to recognize that the concept of academic freedom and the system of tenure are designed to protect Churchill’s rights to pursue controversial ideas. To fire Churchill for saying disagreeable things would be completely at odds with this important ideal.

I don’t agree with the arguments that Professor Churchill presents in his now infamous essay “‘Some People Push Back’ On The Justice of Roosting Chickens.” However, I also think that this essay has been widely misread, and I think Churchill has clarified his position in a number of other statements, most of which have been ignored in the popular press.

But in my mind, the key issue here is not Churchill’s message, but rather the ideal of academic freedom and tenure. Simply put, the fact that Churchill published an essay that is disagreeable– or even “wrong”– is not grounds for his dismissal. As I am sure you are all aware, the point of tenure is to protect the free exchange of ideas, especially when those ideas are controversial and they incite such powerful reactions. This is because it is the exchange of ideas, controversial or not, that makes the concept of a university work. I realize that standing up for Churchill is problematic; but to not stand up for the principle of academic freedom endangers the future of academic thought itself.

This matter brings to mind another news story about free speech that was widely reported just a few days before the Churchill controversy became national news. According to a study John S. and James L Knight Foundation, high school students are woefully ignorant of the protections granted to all Americans by the first amendment. As reported in their press release, three-quarters of high school students thought flag burning was illegal, half believed that the government can censor the Internet, and a third of high school students surveyed thought that the protections of free speech outlined in the first amendment go “too far.”

There was widespread outrage at the ignorance of “today’s youth” regarding one of the fundamental principles and ideals of this country for well over 200 years, free speech. Yet, just a few days later, because Churchill exercised his rights to free speech, there were many calls Churchill’s dismissal in the media (which, of course, is protected by the first amendment) and even in the Colorado legislature (which, one would presume, is familiar with the first amendment of the U.S. Constitution). An even greater ignorance was demonstrated regarding the concept of tenure and academic freedom from all quarters.

My point here is it seems that it is not just high school students in the U.S. who are unaware or even “ignorant” of the concept of free speech.

In closing, I would like to suggest that this current situation gives you, members of the Colorado Board of Regents, a unique opportunity– a “teaching moment,” if you will. I urge you to uphold Churchill’s right to free speech and to honor his tenure and his rights to academic freedom. In doing so, you will have the chance to remind the citizens of Colorado and the U.S. about the importance of free speech, and you will have the opportunity to protect the ideals of academic freedom at both the University of Colorado and beyond.

Sincerely,

Steven D. Krause
Associate Professor, Department of English Language and Literature

Eastern Michigan University * Ypsilanti, MI 48197

http://krause.emich.edu

The threat of boobs loomed large at last week’s Superbowl…

I’m not much of a football fan (particularly pro football), so I didn’t watch much of the “big game.” I do recall catching an ad in the first part of the game for a company called GoDaddy.com (they provide web server space and domain names for cheap) that was kind of funny and a bit “risque.”

The ad featured an attractive model, who is wearing tight jeans and a tank-top shirt, talking to a “censorship committee” about what she can and can’t do in the upcoming GoDaddy.com ad for the Superbowl. In the course of telling and showing what she wants to do, the model has a slight “wardrobe malfunction:” the strap of her tank-top mysteriously breaks, and the model struggles to go on with her presentation while dealing with her shirt. You never actually see anything, but she does have to hold up her shirt, hide under the table, etc. You can see the “approved version” and the whole “uncensored” version of the ad here (be warned– a big download).

Kinda cute, kinda funny, and, IMO, pretty innocent. I mean, I’m not offended by a kind of sexy ad that is an obvious parody of last year’s Superbowl and the current “uptightness” about sex and TV, but I am offended by these beer ads that are some variation on the theme of “my wife/girlfriend is a bitch and isn’t that funny” that I see way too often.

Anyway, in the course of surfing around the ‘net last night, I came across this entry on “Hot Points,” the blog of Bob Parsons, who is the founder and president of GoDaddy.com. Let me quote what Parsons wrote there:

As you may have noticed our Super Bowl ad only appeared during the scheduled first quarter spot. It was scheduled to run also in the second ad position during the final two minute warning. Our ad never ran a second time. Instead, in its place, we saw an advertisement promoting, of all things, “The Simpsons.”

The NFL persuaded FOX to pull our ad.
We immediately contacted Fox to find out what happened. Here’s what we were told: After our first ad was aired, the NFL became upset and they, together with Fox, decided to pull the ad from running a second time. Because we purchased two spots, we were also entitled to a “Brought to you by GoDaddy.com” 5 second marquis spot. They also chose to pull the marquis spot.

Unbelievable. And then, of course, we get a halftime show from that unpredictable and oh-so-current performer, Paul McCartney.

We are living in very uptight times, aren’t we?

Mr. Blogger responds (sort of)

Loyal readers will recall that late last month, I posted about an email I sent to Blogger Headquarters feedback page suggesting that they change the software so that users can set up categories for posts. As I promised in that post, if I received a response, I would post it here.

So here’s the message I received this morning:

Hi there,

I’m afraid we don’t currently have a category feature. However, we are
constantly working on improving Blogger, so we will certainly keep this in
mind for the future. Thanks for the input, and thanks for using Blogger!

Sincerely,

Blogger Support


(Deep sigh.) Duh, I knew that! That’s why I asked! Maybe they really will roll that out in the future though.

Still, I doubt I’m going to make a big jump to something else anytime soon. This is one of those big “crunch times” of the year, where I have a ton of reading and prepping to do for my teaching, where I seem to have meeting after meeting to attend, and where I have literally four different scholarly projects just screaming at me to get done with them. I don’t have the time right now to tweak the CSS on this site, let alone learn something like wordpress or drupal or whatever. Maybe at the the end of the term….

A couple more Social Security Thoughts

I came across this colorful image on an academic blog I read regularly called vitia.org and it got me thinking about a couple of other social security things:

  • Bush and his evil minions are playing off the apathy of the youth, and by “youth,” I potentially mean people like me. In other words, they know that people of my generation and younger have this dismissive view of social security (e.g., “it won’t be around when I retire, so who cares?”), and that gives them their opportunity. They’re sneaky bastards, no doubt about it.
  • I heard an NPR story the other day, the day after the State of the Union address I think, where they were interviewing some guy in a bar, one of these kind of “man on the street” opinion pieces. This guy was all for privatization of social security because he wanted to get his hands on “my money.” In other words, this guy in the bar was under the impression that if social security were privatized, he would literally have the money he is paying as a tax right now in his pocket, and he could do what he wanted with it.

    It strikes me that this is a pretty common misperception about privatization. But the thing is no one is suggesting that. Bush et al have been pretty sneaky in not saying exactly what they’re proposing, but it has been made clear that if the money were to be put aside in a “personal” account, it would still be invested fairly conservatively. And I have to think that these guys in the bar who want “their money” aren’t going to be happy to hear about that.

  • Among other things I think I’ve learned in the talk about Social Security lately is that it isn’t in “crisis” in the sense of total collapse; privatization does nothing to eliminate this “crisis;” and privatization will cost a shitload of money. So, why is Bush so for this?

    I suppose there really is a philosophical difference of opinion here. Bush says he wants the U.S. to move to an “ownership” society, which, I suppose you could argue, is the way it used to be when only white land owners had any power, and when they pretty much “owned” their women and when they literally owned their slaves.

    But I think there’s something else going on here, though to be honest, I don’t know what. Whenever a politician proposes a big and expensive plan, I think it’s always a good idea to try to follow the money. So, who would financially benefit from this kind of plan? I don’t really know, but I would assume this plan would benefit people who are in the finance business: stockbrokers, investment bankers, financial planners, etc. That’s probably a pretty solid Republican block. I don’t know how exactly, but maybe it will benefit people above a certain earning bracket, the kind of person who doesn’t need Social Security in the first place.

    Like I said, I don’t really know. But I am beginning to think there’s something about this proposal that the Bushies know that the rest of us don’t know. Yet.

Two interesting blog revision options

As I’ve written about several times before, I’m pretty sure that I will be sticking with blogger, even when (or maybe “if”) I revise the design/layout of this web site. The main reason boils down to spam spam spam. So very annoying.
Even though I haven’t done anything with the old Moveable Type-driven version of my blog(s) for about a year, I still get spam spam spam on those sites, even with MT-Blacklist installed. What a pain.

Anyway, while I haven’t been seeking out new and improved templates, I’ve come across two kind of interesting possibilities:

  • This cool site from glish.com. I’m not sure I like the color changing thing– it’s kind of cool, but it’s also maybe just a bit much– but it’s kind of an interesting and simple design that seems flexible enough to change to my own needs and desires.
  • These templates from eris: design, which was what Samantha Blackmon was using on her old blog (I still need to update my links to her new blog…).

Really, I think what I want to do is to have the skills/knowledge to modify my blogger template for my own purposes and tastes. I’ve learned A TON about CSS in the last couple weeks, and that’s making me feel a bit more confident. So who knows? Maybe there will be something different soon.

Or maybe I’ll just update this boring template.

Those pesky student evaluations…

When I was at MLA this past year in Philadelphia, my wife and I visited The Chronicle of Higher Education booth at the book fair. Somehow (the first 1,000 visitors? just dumb luck), we managed to get a half-year subscription to the paper version of CHE for a mere dollar. No kidding.

Obviously, the ploy is to get people to sign up for a regular subscription. But considering that I’ve barely looked at the thing since I started receiving it (not to mention the fact that the regular price is something like $82 a year), I don’t think I’ll be doing that. Besides, everything that amuses me in it are available online for free.

For example, take Stanley Fish’s latest, “Who’s In Charge Here?” Essentially, it is a complaint against student evaluations– you know, the bubble-sheet things that college students everywhere fill out nowadays. For the most part, it’s a pretty standard rant against evaluations, and kind of a rambling one in a lot of ways. It doesn’t seem quite as sharp as Fish’s other columns to me.

Anyway, I thought there were a couple of interesting passages:

In the opening paragraphs of the essay, Fish recalls his experiences back in the mid-60s with the then unofficial student evaluation process, which was a student publication at UC Berkeley that published reviews of teacher performance. When negative comments about a faculty member showed up in the official documents for this person’s third year review, Fish

“… protested, saying that if we allowed those unofficial (and unscientific) judgments into our discussions, in time they would become part of the official process. And decisions affecting the career and livelihood of countless junior scholars would be inflected by the ill-informed opinions of transient students with little or no stake in the enterprise who would be free (because they would be anonymous) to indulge any sense of grievance they happened to harbor in the full knowledge that nothing they said would ever be questioned or challenged.

“Nothing like that, a senior colleague assured me solemnly, could ever happen. Faculty members would always be able to distinguish between anecdotal evidence from a questionable source and the hard evidence of publication and research.

“The rest, as they say, is history.”

I don’t know exactly why, but this passage sort of amuses and comforts me. I think this is the case because it suggests that students were pretty much the same sort of “consumers” looking for “entertainment” from their teachers. It’s not as if Fish is saying “in the good old days, students used to give good feedback on evaluations; now look what they do.”

A bit later in the essay, Fish writes:

“So there in brief is my brief (not only mine; the points have been made before by many) against student evaluations: They are randomly collected. They are invitations to grind axes without any fear of challenge or discovery. They are based on assumptions that have more to do with pop psychology or self-help or customer satisfaction than with the soundness of one’s pedagogy. A whole lot of machinery with a very small and dubious yield.

“But don’t students have a right to competent and responsible instruction? You bet they do (and this is the only sense I can give to the phrase “student rights”), and that is why I approve of those questions that go right to the heart of what responsible instruction is — course planning, reasonable and rewarding assignments, up-to-date and pertinent readings, generous and helpful feedback, the meeting of curricular expectations, and so on.”

Fair enough; I think this is how most teachers feel.

Personally, I think student evaluations are useful in the sense of showing a pattern. I mean, if you only have two or three students in a class of 25 who say something (negative or positive) about some particular aspect of your teaching (an assignment, a reading, a particular approach, your attitude,whatever), well, that doesn’t mean much. The other 23 or so didn’t seem to care enough to mention it. On the other hand, if you have 20 out of 25 students say something about your teaching, then I think it’s a good idea to take those comments seriously.

I give up…

Well, no, not really. But sometimes I wonder….

What I’m talking about here is this news story I heard on NPR earlier this week talking about new federal guidelines for exercise. Basically, the government thinks that everyone needs 60 to 90 minutes of exercise a day, every day. Who the hell has time to do that?! Let’s see: there are the people I guess you would call the “gym divas,” these women (mostly) who apparently have no other commitments other than exercise; college “students” who have decided that there time is better spent on the treadmill; professional athletes and trainers; and that’s about it.

So what’s the freakin’ point?

Fortunately, the NPR story pointed out that it is indeed pretty unrealistic for the average (or even not so average) person. The other question I had was about the definition of exercise. I mean, at work, I bet I spend a total of a good hour walking around, up and down stairs, down to the main office, etc. Does that count?

Anyway, I won’t give up this week. Maybe next.