The new style manual is here! The new style manual is here!

How big of a nerdy English/writing type of person does one need to be to appreciate the fact that the MLA has come out with a new edition of the style manual?  And does it make me an even bigger looser enthusiast that the first thing I want to look at in the newest issue of The Journal of Electronic Publishing is a review of this new style manual?

Regardless, it’s an interesting piece by Kevin S. Hawkins, who is an electronic publishing librarian over at the University of Michigan.  The rest of the journal looks interesting this time around too.  Based on what Hawkins is saying, it sounds like MLA has made some advances in dealing with electronic resources and in acknowledging the fact that almost all of the writing/editing done in academic/humanities-type journals involves computers.

And for me, this observation brought back unpleasant memories:  “I’m glad to see that two holdovers from the days of the typewriter have finally been put to rest: underlining and double spacing after periods are out, and italicization and single spacing are in.”  Twelve years ago, when I was trying to wrap up my dissertation in the summer before I began my first tenure-track job, I was in an epic (well, for me) battle with a thesis/dissertation reader in the Bowling Green State University graduate college.

In those days (I assume this is still true, though I don’t typically have to deal with such things at EMU because our graduate students do “projects” and not “theses” that adhere to such strict rules), this was the final stop for a dissertation, a hoop soon-to-be PhDs had to jump through even after a defense.  The staff in this office was made up mostly of MA students on an assistantship, and their job was to proof-read for your run-of-the-mill errors and for adherence to a style manual– in my case, the MLA style manual.  This reviewer did catch a number of errors I was able to tidy up, but this person (who was always anonymous to me) also tried to argue that I had to eliminate all contractions (I dare you to find that rule in the MLA style manual) and to change all italics into underlined text.  I had a lot of italics in my diss, both for book titles but also for emphasis— probably a little too much emphasis– and I thought then (and think now) that underlining is ugly.

Well, long-story a bit shorter, I actually went back and forth via email with this person for a while, and I ultimately had to get a “supervisor” involved in order to remind this office that I had successfully defended my dissertation.  I ended up presenting this person with a quote from that edition of the MLA style manual (the second?) which said italics were at least an acceptable substitute for underlining.  I finished, went on with my life, and became the tenured professor you see before you today.  I don’t know whatever happened to this reviewer, but I am guessing they are not happy with these new MLA changes.

Depending on what happens with English 328 next year, perhaps this could be a reading for that class….

I’m for Edupunk, but “easy listening” style

Glen Blalock forwarded a link to an interesting little article in the CHE, “Frustrated With Corporate Course-Management Systems, Some Professors Go ‘Edupunk’.” The article is quite short and there are a number of good links, so no point in summing them all up here. Basically, “edupunk” is the same as what a lot of people in the computers and writing community have been doing for a long time, which is by-passing university run CMS rules in favor of “do it yourself” (DIY), free, and/or open source options.

Interestingly enough, I think I’ve kind of come back around to the value of the university sponsored CMS.

Don’t get me wrong– I’m all for these Edupunkers, and it seems to me that if you’re teaching courses like the ones I teach and like the ones most of my colleagues in the computers and writing world teach, it makes sense to incorporate some “real” web and/or Web 2.0 (whatever that is) writing situations into the mix. Keeping the whole thing in a CMS is a little too stagnant for me, and for most of the classes I teach, it just makes sense to use tools like blogs, wikis, photo sites like Flickr, Google docs, YouTube or other video sites, etc. Why use some watered-down CMS version of this software when students can use open and better sites for free? Edupunk in this sense is about keepin’ it real.

On the other hand, the problem with doing all of a class punk/DIY style is that you really do have to do the whole thing yourself to make it work. And I guess the hard thing to figure out is where cost of doing it yourself becomes too much: too much time, too much money (if you have to lease server space) and I guess too much anxiety at the responsibility of it all. If emuonline goes down, that’s their problem and they will hear holy heck from me and my students until it’s fixed. But if the site I am using with Blogger or on stevendkrause.com or some other site goes down, well, then that’s my problem, and I don’t like creating any more problems for myself than absolutely necessary.

So I like my Edupunk teaching tools, but I know I still have to have my pop for the masses teaching tools as well.

Computers and Composition, the “Top 25”

Out of a discussion on Tech-Rhet the other day came this little tidbit from Bill HD: ScienceDirect (which indexes Computers and Composition) has a “Hottest 25” feature for various journals. So, for example, here’s a link to the “hottest 25” articles (in terms of people accessing them at least, I assume) in Computers and Composition from the October-December 2007 issues.

Since this site also has a handy “blog it” feature and there are some articles I can imagine teaching next year, I think I’ll go ahead and link those below as well:

Understanding”Internet plagiarism”
• Article
Computers and Composition, Volume 24, Issue 1, 1 January 2007, Pages 3-15
Howard, R.M.

Gains and losses: New forms of texts, knowledge, and learning
• Article
Computers and Composition, Volume 22, Issue 1, 1 January 2005, Pages 5-22
Kress, G.

The fair use doctrine: History, application, and implications for (new media) writing teachers
• Article
Computers and Composition, Volume 24, Issue 2, 1 March 2007, Pages 154-178
Rife, M.C.


Why Napster matters to writing: Filesharing as a new ethic of digital delivery
• Article
Computers and Composition, Volume 23, Issue 2, 1 January 2006, Pages 178-210
DeVoss, D.N.; Porter, J.E.

 
Weathering wikis: Net-based learning meets political science in a South African university
• Article
Computers and Composition, Volume 24, Issue 3, 1 June 2007, Pages 266-284
Carr, T.; Morrison, A.; Cox, G.; Deacon, A.

(I did teach this one this past year, actually.)


Plagiarism, originality, assemblage
• Article
Computers and Composition, Volume 24, Issue 4, 1 September 2007, Pages 375-403
Johnson-Eilola, J.; Selber, S.A.

 
CMS-based simulations in the writing classroom: Evoking genre through game play
• Article
Computers and Composition, Volume 24, Issue 2, 1 March 2007, Pages 179-197
Fisher, D.

Computers and Writing 2008: Krause’s Big Wrap-Up

First off, let me back-track a bit and fill in a few more details on what I’ve already mentioned about C&W and this trip:

  • The “very good session” I went to on Friday morning before Jay David Bolter’s talk featured Rik Hunter, Dan Anderson, and Alex Reid. Follow the links for more info on the presentations. Actually, in Rik’s and Dan’s case, you can literally see what they did: both of them had everything pre-recorded and just “delivered” it by cranking up the computer and pushing play. Alex did his the old fashioned way– just talking. All were very good, but it was kind of strange to see the presenter standing there while his movie plays his presentation.
  • Speaking of Alex Reid, congratulations on the John Lovas Memorial Academic Weblog Award for Digital Digs!
  • I wish Jay David Bolter’s talk was online someplace, and maybe it will be at some point– they videotaped it. I thought it would be a really interesting teaching tool because he made a bridge/connection between the hypertext experiments of the early 90’s (remember StorySpace?) with gaming experiments (newsgaming.com, for example), poetry that plays on your iPod or your cell phone when you are in certain points of the Atlanta subway, a podcast tour of a cemetery, etc. It reminds me that I need to work gaming back into English 516 the next time I teach it.

Now on to the “part 3” or concluding episode of Computers and Writing 2008 from my pov:

  • My session was at 10 AM on Saturday, and the “prime time” seemed to help us draw a pretty decent-sized crowd. Before me was Gian Pugnucci with a talk called “The WikiBib Project: Exploring the nature of Teaching Collaborative Scholarships in a Wiki.” Basically, he was talking about using a wiki as a means of facilitating collaboration on an annotated bibliography assignment in a graduate class. I’ve talked with Gian about this before and I think we’re going to try and work something out together on this for his and my grad courses next year.

    I was second, and I’ll pretty much let my presentation speak (or not) for itself:

    A slight tangent here: I actually managed to forget the do-hickey for hooking up my laptop, so I spent a few moments thinking I was screwed. But it turns out I was doubly covered. Since this was the computers and writing conference after all, someone in the audience (Carl Whithaus, actually) immediately volunteered his adapter. But besides that, the fine folks in Georgia were completely prepared for this, too. The guy doing tech support for UGa told me he had a whole bag full of the adapters I needed and was very confident that he could get the projector set-up to work. Quite a contrast to the way the projectors often work (or not) in Pray-Harrold.Anyway, I got some great feedback from folks on what to do with the whole “finished blogger” issue, and as we discussed during the session, my use of the word “failure” in my talk is probably not right. “Not finished,” “abandoned, or and as often as not, “ended at the appropriate time” are probably better terms. In any event, helpful ideas from attendees.

    The third presenter was Natalie Szymanski from Florida State with a talk titled “Wikis and Composition Pedagogy: Avoiding the Bandwagon.” Basically, she was suggesting that maybe we ought to slow down a bit on all of this stuff like wikis. While I didn’t agree with many of the things she had to say, I had to give her credit because it’s nice to see someone at this conference have the guts to point out that we’re in the “writing business” and not the “isn’t this software I just learned about cool business.”

  • And then it was time for golf. I was part of a foursome with Steve Benninghoff, Gian, and Nick Carbone out at the University of Georgia Golf Course. In hind-sight, I think we should have picked a more “accessible” course since Benninghoff and I could have used a bit of a “palate cleanser” after the challenges of that course in Kentucky, and Gian and Nick, neither of whom had swung a club in over a year, could have just used something easier. This was one bad-assed hard hard course, certainly in the top 2 or 3 in difficulty that I’ve played, and a course that made me wish for an easy one like Pierce Lake or Eagle Crest.

    But hey, it was a friendly game, and a good time was had by one and all even if the play wasn’t great. Actually, it got a lot more fun when we started the back nine and we played a cart versus cart scramble, but Nick had to leave a little early, so it just kind of degenerated into some sloppy play at the end of a long death march of a round.

  • Steve B. and Gian and I had some BBQ that I thought was pretty so-so, and then we went off to Kingpins Bowl and Brew for the ritual of the bowling night. I managed to catch up with a few folks who I didn’t get a chance to talk to much during the conference itself (including Courtney, who is doing great), had a few more Terapins, and even managed a little bowling (I scored 100– I had forgotten that real bowling isn’t as easy as Wii bowling).
  • And then Sunday was the long drive home. I managed to prod my more leisurely traveling companion onto the road by 6:30 and we were back in Ypsilanti in less than 12 hours, which, when I think about the expense and general pain in the butt of flying, makes me think that driving was a good idea, with or without the golf.

So an excellent conference/roadtrip. Well done, UGa, folks! Here are some pictures of the whole things– eventually, I’ll add some info about all these pictures.

Next year, C&W is going to be at UC-Davis and it is going to be toward the end of June. I don’t know if I’ll be going yet or not, to tell the truth. On the down-side, the CCCCs is in San Francisco this year, and I don’t think I can afford 2 trips to California just to conference. On the other hand, Annette and Will and I might want to make this part of a west coast “pilgrimage” back to Ashland. We shall see….

Nfomedia– anybody out there use this yet?

I was invited by someone (who knows who?) to join Nofomedia, which is a free and stupid-easy course management system built like a social networking tool.  I have spent about 10 minutes looking at this since I have a ton of other things I have to do after the Computers and Writing trip– unpack, mow the lawn, get caught up with my classes, laundry, shopping, etc.– but I have to say this looks pretty compelling to me.

I think the biggest challenge/problem these folks are likely to have is the same problem/challenge that any software that isn’t the “official”software option of an institution is likely to have.  But it’s definitely worth checking out.

Is the MacArthur Foundation Series on Digital Media and Learning still Open Source?

Maybe it’s just a temporary thing, but I’m a little miffed right now:

The John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation sponsored a great series on “Digital Media and Learning,” and worked out a deal with MIT press where you can order the print version or you can download the open source version for free. Here’s a link to that site.

However, when I tried just now to browse through one of these open source publications, the MIT press gives me an error and says that the file wasn’t found. What gives? Did someone have “take-backs” on these once free articles?

Update, May 26:

I’m happy to say I am wrong– all of this stuff still is available as PDF downloads. The site just appeared to be down for a while.

Gaming helps 21st century students

Article/link #2 I don’t want to lose when I reboot: “Gaming helps students hone 21st-century skills,” from eNews and its annoying password/account-driven web site. The sub-head specifically singles out sites like Second Life. A couple paragraphs:

Sharnell Jackson, the chief eLearning officer for Chicago Public Schools and the webinar’s moderator, noted that gaming and simulations are highly interactive, allow for instant feedback, immerse students in collaborative environments, and allow for rapid decision-making. The webinar was sponsored by the Consortium for School Networking (CoSN).

Studies of the brain have pointed to data suggesting that repeated exposure to video games reinforces the ability to create mental maps, inductive discovery such as formulating hypotheses, and the ability to focus on several things at once and respond faster to unexpected stimuli.

Which reminds me that the next time I teach English 516, I’m going to have to once again re-add the units on gaming and writing.