Here is yet another EMU-centric post about Gen Ed Revisions happening here at EMU. This is a follow-up to my previous post about this, which I wrote before the campus “town hall” meetings where anyone/everyone was invited to ask questions and talk about the Gen Ed changes. Here’s a link to the PDF of that proposal.
There were three town hall meetings. I attended the first one on October 26, held on Zoom, and I think around 75 people were logged in at its peak. One of my colleagues went to the second session, which was held f2f on October 29, and he said it had 30 people. I went to the last of these sessions held on November 3; it too was f2f and with about 30 attending.
I have some thoughts, and just to be clear: once again, I am speaking only for myself; these are merely my opinions and observations; this doesn’t reflect the views of anyone else in my school; etc., etc.
For starters, I think the committee Provost Schecter put together to do this had an impossible and thankless task, so I have to cut everyone involved a bit of slack, give everyone a bit of grace, etc. For whatever reason, the plan is to revise all of the gen ed outcomes by January and to launch this plan (and we have yet to see the final version) in Fall 2027 because this deadline cannot possibly be extended. So I get that this committee didn’t have a lot of time to do any real research or to develop a real plan for revising Gen Ed.
Nonetheless, the overall problem I have with these Gen Ed revisions at this stage is that they are being rushed through based on no research and no real plan. It doesn’t have to be that way because if the provost’s and president’s goals are to reduce the size of Gen Ed RIGHT NOW, there is an extremely simple way to do that: just follow the Michigan Transfer Agreement. I’ll come back to that point later.
I am most concerned about the proposed changes to Gen Ed in the “Effective Communication” category, which would (potentially?) make it so that WRTG 121 (our composition course) and COMM 124 (our speech course) were no longer specifically required. Instead, it would be in a category that might “contain more than two courses moving forward; however, the total number of courses will remain small.” I think I now kind of understand what that odd phrase means, actually.
Before I get into the details, I have two big picture takeaways. First, there was a lot of the discussion about the changes to this category currently called “Effective Communication” that will potentially be renamed “Inquiry, Expression, and Critical Thinking”– and I’ll come back to the problems with this name later as well. Second, I did not hear anyone at either of the meetings I attended or from anyone else in person or emails or whatever who thought eliminating either WRTG 121 and COMM 124 as required courses was a good idea. Quite the opposite, which again begs the question I asked at the end of my first Gen Ed post: what’s the motivation for this change to the category with composition and speech?
To sum up the Gen Ed changes: To reduce the number of Gen Ed credits from the current 41 to 31 and to fit more closely with the MTA, Natural Sciences, Social Sciences, Humanities, and Arts all went from 2 courses to 1, and the US and Global Awareness categories, which used to have 1 course each, went down to 1 course in a combined category. Incidentally, combining those two categories/courses was the other most contentious change being proposed.
At the beginning of the Zoom town hall, one of the members of the committee briefly summarized the rationale for these changes. During that summary, this person said that the reason why “Effective Communication” is being renamed to “Inquiry, Expression, and Critical Thinking” and why there will be (in some indeterminate future) courses in topics like argumentative writing and visual communication is to make up for the cuts to the humanities and arts categories. Why? Because it wasn’t “fair” that Composition and Communication were the only areas where the course requirements remained the same. Well, okay then.
During this Zoom town hall, I raised my virtual hand and asked a question based on what I wrote in my previous post about Gen Ed: the MTA specifically requires an “English Composition Class,” and that is not a class on any subject where writing is assigned. I also pointed out that 95% of universities in the US require a specific composition course (and honestly, that percentage is probably higher), and all of the other universities and colleges in the MTA that are regional public universities like EMU require a specific course. So if EMU no longer did that, we would no longer be following the MTA. Besides making the institution an extreme outlier among universities and colleges in the U.S., this would make it a lot harder for students who took the non-composition course to transfer from EMU to another MTA university.
The way I phrased my question was that I wondered if the committee was aware of this specific requirement of the MTA, and if they had a problem with becoming one of the few universities in the country without a required composition course? I don’t know if this is actually true or not, but the answer to the first part of my question seemed to be no: the committee was not aware of the specificity of an “English composition” course, and that pretty much every college requires a specific composition course. As for the problems created if a student wants to transfer to another MTA school without a composition course, the response from someone on the committee was along the lines of “Our charge (from the Provost) was to make it easier for students to transfer to EMU, not to make it easier for students to transfer from EMU.” Okay….
I went to the last of the town hall meetings as well. Once again, I commented about the MTA requirements, and about how English Composition is universal requirement in U.S. higher education. I also asked a question that had been nagging me ever since this proposal was circulated. For the category that is currently called “Effective Communication” and where the two courses are first-year writing and speech, the proposal says the “foundational courses” will also include courses in “argumentative writing” and “visual communication.” Also, there is a table on page 7 of the Gen Ed proposal that still calls this area “Effective Communication,” and the notation on the table reads “This category may contain more than two courses moving forward; however, the total number of courses will remain small.” So, my question was if anyone on the committee could name an existing course as an example of one of these other courses that would fit into this category. The answer was along the lines of “well, we’ve been thinking about developing an argumentation course.” In other words, no, there isn’t another existing course.
One other thing that came out of the last town hall discussion and that I had heard before was that the provost believed no category of gen ed should be a “monopoly” that was “owned” by a single unit or department or whatever. In other words, part of the logic of putting a (hypothetical) art course or a philosophy course into the same category as English composition and Communication is so that category wasn’t “controlled” by what were two departments but now that is one school in the College of Arts and Sciences.
It is true that none of the other categories of Gen Ed are taught by only one unit. Of course, the only reason why the required composition and speech courses are now in the same school is that when the dean (with the urging and support of the provost and president) rearranged the college, she put what were two different departments (the “Communications” part of what was Communications, Media, and Theater Arts, along with English) into the same school. In other words, the so-called monopoly the provost is against was created by the dean and with the help and encouragement of the provost.
But is this about a “monopoly” or is it about a “discipline?”
The reason why the “English Composition” and “Communication” courses are overseen and taught by composition and speech faculty is because that is our discipline. This is what we do. This is a specialization just as real as any of the other disciplines/areas of Gen Ed.
Further, all of the other categories of Gen Ed (other than the interdisciplinary category now called “Perspectives on a Diverse World” with the proposed new name of “Community and Social Responsibility”) are cartels of disciplines: that is, the natural science category is biology, chemistry, earth sciences, and physics; the arts category is limited to the disciplines of art, theater, and dance; the humanities category is limited to disciplines like literature, history, philosophy; and so forth. In other words, this proposal seems to recognize the disciplinarity of the other categories of Gen Ed; just not the category with writing and speech. After all, we all write and speak, right?
Interestingly enough, I was on the Faculty Senate (then called Faculty Council) in 2004 when the current Gen Ed was being debated, and there were some weird conversations about disciplinarity definitions and borders back then as well. As I recall it, there was a surprisingly long discussion about how a hypothetical physics class focusing on art could fit into the arts category. After all, art is everywhere; why should we limit gen ed courses in the art category to just the discipline of art? Needless to say, that argument didn’t go very far.
So again, no, we shouldn’t eliminate the require English Composition course and the required speech course, and my sense is that a significant majority of my EMU colleagues feel the same way.
I want to end by returning to two things I brought up earlier:
First, I understand the administration’s desires to make big changes and shake things up in order to do something that might raise our enrollments. I don’t think anyone decides on what college to attend based on Gen Ed, but I can see how reducing the number of required courses makes sense. But besides the fact that the timeline for completing these revisions is unrealistic, the process is backwards. If the goal is to completely rethink/revise Gen Ed, then the committee in charge of this should begin by revising the learning outcomes. Instead, what appears to be happening is the proposal is going to be a list of courses and the outcomes are going to be developed based on that.
I think a more sensible way to approach this is to make it a two-phase process. Start by lining up our Gen Ed with the MTA, though with 31 credits since one of the sciences should have a lab. We could easily start doing this in Fall 2027. Then begin phase two, a more thoughtful process designed to address the “Notable Features/Potential Opportunities” of a revised Gen Ed that is specified in the proposal. This includes things like broadening the Celebration of Student Writing, creating “themes” of gen ed courses, and promoting what the proposal calls “high-impact practices.” In other words, let’s aim before we shoot.
Second, the category name “Inquiry, Expression, and Critical Thinking” is not good. I know “critical thinking” is kind of a buzzy term and all, but I always wonder: as opposed to what? Uncritical thinking? Lazy thinking? I mean, what does that really mean, and what class does not engage in critical thinking? “Inquiry” and “Expression” are just as vague and broad: pretty every college class is a form of inquiry, and if students actually speak and write about that inquiry, they’re expressing themselves. We can revisit the current category title of “Effective Communication,” but changing the name to something so broad and baggy that literally any course taught at EMU could fit into it is a bad idea.
