Facebook taking over the world ala Microsoft

Or at least that’s the possible claim in this TechCrunch post, “Could Facebook Become The Next Microsoft?” This is kind of a wonky post about Facebook seems to be going the route of Microsoft in the past and Google in the present in becoming the number one destination on the internet by incorporating all sorts of different applications and the like.

I don’t know much about that, but I do know that Facebook has become more popular in my own house recently: my wife, Annette Wannamaker,
has joined the Facebook party.

"Access" isn't the problem

I posted about this on this entry on Alex’s blog digital digs, and I thought then about posting a comment on Jeff’s blog too. But then I decided to just write more about it here:

Both Alex and Jeff are commenting on the Council of Writing Program Administrators statement about technology, which sets minimal goals in terms of computer/technology skills for both students and instructors, I presume because the writers of this plank/document are still stuck on the possibility of a lack of access. To quote from this document:

Although we were drawn to the rhetoric of interweaving technology with the other goals of writing instruction, we decided not to chance disrupting sections that have already met with approval from our colleagues not only in rhetoric and composition but in other fields as well. By drafting this technology section, we have kept in mind the many colleges and universities where neither students nor teachers have ready access to digital technologies or the Internet. Indeed, we know of some schools in which teachers do not feel they can require typed copy, let alone electronic submissions. Keeping these schools in mind, we have drafted a statement that we hope will give them reasonable objectives without outdistancing their possibilities altogether, leaving them alienated from our shared purposes in teaching required writing courses.

Alex points to a variety of surveys– one from Circuit City (??) and one a 2004 Harris survey– that suggest that computer saturation/access at the college-level is very high. He does agree that expecting students at the first year level to do a lot of multimedia work probably isn’t possible (and I don’t think that would be a good idea, personally), but there needs to be some clarity on the term “text.” Jeff argues that forming a national policy on the exception (e.g., someone doesn’t have access to a computer) rather than the norm is a bad idea.

Go and read both of those posts, but I thought I’d throw a couple of other things out there:

  • By the time I started teaching first year composition in 1988, writing with a computer was the “normal” thing to do. I required students to type the final drafts of the essays they handed in, and I also required students to write at least one of those essays with a computer or a word processor. I did have a few students back then who told me that they couldn’t do this because they didn’t know how to type– and I would always tell those students that this will be an excellent opportunity to learn– but I never had a student tell me back then that they simply could not get to a computer. This was almost 20 years ago, and it was at Virginia Commonwealth University, a very inner-city and “opportunity granting” kind of institution, certainly not the kind of school where one could assume that all students would show up with a laptop.
  • The problem of access is a common topic in English 516, the grad course I teach on computers and writing pedagogy. In fact, it comes up so much in that class that I might have to “ban” it as a research topic, sort of along the lines of banning topics like abortion, the death penalty, gay parenting, legalizing marijuana, God, or the one you love from first year composition. Like those generic topics in fyc, the “access problem” is a knee-jerk/easy-to-come-up-with topic, and not a lot of my past students have not been able to successfully write about it, either.
  • Here’s my own responses on the access issue when it comes up, and it always comes up (I gave a little talk about blogging recently and the topic came up, for example): first, we live in a world where something like one billion people don’t have access to clean drinking water and/or electricity. Think about that for a second– folks like us are getting all keyed up about who does or doesn’t have access to a computer, and there is a significant proportion of the world’s population who couldn’t plug a computer in and who have a lot bigger worries than Internet access. Now, what should we do about this? Should those of us who have access to water and electricity help those who don’t have access around the world? Of course, and we should as a matter of national policy help them more than we do. Should those of us with this access give it up because so many folks don’t have it? Of course not.

    Second, I think that student access at all levels (and in my experiences with English 516, most of the access problems center on the more legitimate problems of access at the secondary level) is a lot better than most teachers think. It seems to me the popularity of things like MySpace and Facebook are evidence enough of that. I sometimes have colleagues here who say they can’t do “x” with computer technology because they don’t teach in a computer lab. Well, I often teach in a computer lab, and I will agree that it is very convenient, especially for demonstration purposes. But getting students to do some basic things– blogging, participating in an email discussion, working online collaboratively on revising/rewriting something (I’m thinking here of Google Docs), chatting with each other, setting up groups with social network sites like Facebook, etc., etc.– these don’t require ubiquitous computer access.
  • Fundamentally, I think the “problem of access” is, at best, a way of avoiding some legitimate debate about the role of technology in writing pedagogy, or, at worse, an excuse for not doing something different. By “legitimate debate,” I mean the question of the role of various computer technologies in the teaching of writing. I think blogging, email, etc., are good tools to incorporate into a first year composition class, though I am less sold on things like iMovie or Flash or even simple web page construction. These are specifics where different points of view seem legitimate to me.

    But to be honest, I think that what most many a lot of comp/rhet-types are using access as an excuse so that they themselves don’t have to learn all of this messy computer stuff, and also so that a lot of comp/rhet-types don’t have to change the way they’ve always done things.

Wikipedia corrects Britannica

A handy snippet from the Huffington Post for teaching English 516 or 444, where there are always students who have no confidence at all in things like wikipedia and who trust without question things like print encyclopedias:

“Despite all the controversy about Wikipedia’s work model, no one can argue the potential of a project that has so effectively demonstrated the usefulness of the ‘wisdom of crowds’ concept. And that wisdom has detected a large number of mistakes in one of the most revered founts of human knowledge, the Encyclopedias Britannica. Among the wrong information collected on this page are the name at birth of Bill Clinton and the definition of the NP problems in mathematics.”

BAWS: Debating the role of blogs and a couple of items potentially worth reading

A couple days ago, I wrote about the Wall Street Journal Online article about the tenth anniversary of weblogs. I guess WSJ online is running a series or something, because today (via boingboing) I came across this, “The Good, the Bad, and the Web 2.0.” It’s a debate between a couple of folks who have books I ought to at least browse through:

“Andrew Keen, who wrote “The Cult of the Amateur,” argues the Web has become overwhelmed with useless noise. David Weinberger, author of “Everything is Miscellaneous,” argues that Web 2.0 tools let users filter out irrelevant (or inaccurate) information.”

I haven’t read the debate yet though….

Misc. Readings from "Up North"

While I was on vacation with family last week (the curious can read a few things about it here), I did do a little light blog reading, in part with the help of the off-line function for Google Reader. I don’t think I’ve quite figured out how to use it correctly, but I did manage to star a few items that I thought I’d mention here:

"Happy Blogiversary," from WSJ.com

Just as I am ready to get back from vacation and ease into quasi-sabbatical mode, I stumbled across this article, “Happy Blogiversary,” from the WSJ.com. It is a pretty good and rather long article that spells out the “state of affairs” of blogging, at least from the point of view of a rather conservative newspaper about the world of business. This is certainly something that would be useful to teach a variety of different classes for sure.

Actually, it’s one of those articles that, in relationship to my “Blogs as Writerly Spaces” project, I find simultaneously really helpful and really intimidating. It’s helpful because it features a number of famous and semi-famous folks– bloggers and not– talking about why they read/write blogs, and it includes some interesting history. But it’s intimidating because it is one of those articles that, in very basic terms, probably sums up the point I’m trying to make with this project. And if my project can be summed up in a WSJ article, well, is my sabbatical project really a project?

These are normal doubts and misgivings at the beginning of a big project like this, I suppose. It feels a little like working on my dissertation. I recall going through these oscillations where I felt like my diss was literally about everything and therefore impossible, and/or that my diss was common sense and therefore irrelevant. I suspect this project will take some similar turns.

Oh well. I’m just easing into this project. The first things I’m going to do is read and clean my desk, so it’ll be a while before I have to doubt myself too much.

danah boyd myspace v. facebook article (and a BAWS example?)

Via jill/txt, I came across this entry from apophenia (Danah Boyd’s blog) called “viewing American class divisions through Facebook and MySpace.” I think it’s interesting, though not necessarily because of the subject matter. Boyd (or, I guess I should say, boyd) more or less argues that there is a class difference between users of MySpace and Facebook– I’ve only skimmed the article, but most of her claims seem reasonable albeit sweeping. For example, she suggests that teens from poorer backgrounds are more likely to be on MySpace than Facebook. That might be true, though at EMU, I’m always surprised by the number of my juniors and seniors who have almost no experience with either of these services.

In any event, I’m not really that interested in boyd’s argument per se (though I think this link could be useful in a class like English 516 or English 444 in a discussion about social bookmarking software), mainly because I have a really hard time getting too excited about either one of these services. I realize this is a bad attitude because there are serious people out there– like boyd, for example– who do serious scholarly work on these Internet environments.

What I’m more interested in is how this figures into my Blogs as writerly spaces project– at least in my own head. boyd wrote this essay– I do not know if she was deadly serious about it or if it was just a toss-off piece– and posted it to her blog. Suddenly, she’s getting a ton of comments and even reflecting here on this unusual level of attention. Her reaction in some ways seems similar to my own reaction on my blog when I was getting an insane number of hits posting about the EMU faculty strike. But while I felt compelled to write even more as a result of this new-found audience, boyd seems to be not that thrilled with the attention. In fact, this post suggests a certain level of “stop bugging me about this already.”

Now, I’m just brainstorming here, and I don’t really know how much of this figures into what BAWS will look like ultimately. I mean, boyd is already something of an internet celebrity, so I presume she’s used to the attention. I am not sure this particular essay has much of an impact in terms of her motivations to write or not write on a blog, though I suppose it has created an unusual exigency from her point of view. It also occurs to me now that a lot of what we’re talking about here is what can only be described as a viral text– and I have no idea why I haven’t made that connection up to this point. In my C&W presentation, I talked about the role that search engines and such figure into the functioning of rhetorical situations, and I think it’s begining to gel more clearly in my head that it is something like this.

And that ain’t that clear, is it?

In any event, I’m going to be following danah’s blog for a while, and we’ll see where it goes with this idea….

"Podcasts replace textbooks for GATE students"

This is an especially misleading headline, but it is what it is: Podcasts replace textbook for GATE students, from the Mohave Daily News. Happily, looking at the first couple of paragraphs proves that they aren’t throwing away the textbooks exactly:

Instead of pouring over textbooks and completing worksheets, students at Diamondback Elementary School are making podcasts, creating virtual tours of fictional museums and putting together their autobiographies with digital cameras.

The Gifted And Talented Enrichment (GATE) program – offered year-round for kindergarten through eighth grade in the Bullhead City School District – launched a four-week summer program this year that has students working on MacBooks.

The MacBook runs both Apple and Windows systems, compared to the Windows-only computers the district currently uses, and has a built-in system that can take still photos and record audio and video.

Oh yeah– it’s kind of an ad for Apple, too.

This is an article that I hope is around in terms of a link next year when I teach English 516 again because it’s another one of those examples to me of the difference between just dumping laptops in the schools (and then being shocked– SHOCKED, I tell you!– when that doesn’t work) and actually integrating technology into pedagogy in a way that makes sense.